I love the use of “site” in this clue. For a great many modern solvers, “site,” especially in the context of a holiday, is going to suggest somewhere you can get stuff on the web, possibly last minute. (This is assuredly reinforced by the humorous clue directly above it, Requested pickup time on many online orders (4) for ASAP.) And “holiday gift orders” keeps it open enough such that the mind might not even immediately go to Commercemas. But no, no, no, we are in fact talking about the red-suited, white-bearded man himself (and not his propensity for slapping elves, if you parsed it the wrong way). “Orders,” too is a nice word choice: not wishes, but the directives of spoiled, needy children. I feel humbuggish at this point, so let me course correct by repeating how much I enjoyed seeing the final answer, SANTA’S LAP. Other good stuff in the puzzle includes What Graham Green called a “failure of the imagination” (4)–and if you’re going to do a quote clue, make it at least as good as this description of HATE–and Totally misses …or totally surveys (9), which is one of those fun “the word can mean itself or an antonym, isn’t English great?” aka OVERLOOK.
- Daniel Bodily and Jeff Chen, The New York Times, 3/17/22